While silk exhibits high values of tensile strength and stiffness, these properties are compromised by their poor reproducibility. We present the results of experiments aimed at characterizing the variability of tensile properties exhibited by cocoon silk from Bombyx mori silkworms. Scanning electron microscopy is used to measure an average diameter for individual test specimens; the interspecimen variability of diameter is quantified and found to be inadequately represented by standard deviation. When load-extension data are converted into stress-strain curves, a marked improvement in reproducibility is realized if each specimen cross-section is calculated hom diameter measurements specific to that specimen. Nevertheless, a significant variability in fracture stress remains; a Weibull analysis reveals that silkworm silk has a failure predictability comparable with that of glass and nonengineering ceramics. Unloading/reloading tests demonstrate that stiffness is not significantly affected by cumulative deformation, and the stress-strain relationship is not sensitive to strain rate.