The natural products pyrroindomycins (PYRs), active against various drug-resistant pathogens, possess a characteristic, cyclohexene ring spiro-linked tetramate moiety. In this study, investigation into PYR biosynthesis revealed two new proteins, both of which, phylogenetically distinct from but functionally substitutable to each other in vivo, individually catalyze a Dieckmann cyclization in vitro for converting an N-acetoacetyl-L-alanyl thioester into a tetramate. Their counterparts are commonly present in the biosynthetic pathways of spiro and polyether tetronates, supporting a uniform paradigm for tetronate/tetramate formation, which features an enzymatic way to generate the C-X (X = O or N) bond first and the C-C bond next in building of the 5-membered heterocycle.