Changing pressure from 1 to 2500 bar continuously tunes free energy changes for electron attachment to molecules in nonpolar liquids by nearly 0.3 eV. Rate constants for electron attachment to substituted benzoquinones were determined over an extended free energy range of nearly 1 eV by a combination of solute, pressure, temperature, and use of solvents with differing energies of the quasifree electron, V-0: tetramethylsilane (TMS) and 2,2,4-trimethylpentane (TMP). The rates of attachment to both benzoquinone (BQ) and 2,5-dichlorobenzoquinone in TMS increase as the pressure increases to 2500 bar, while in TMP the rates are higher but change little with pressure; the rate of attachment to fluoranil in TMS is similarly high at 1 bar but decreases with increasing pressure. Together the observed rate constants can be qualitatively interpreted to yield a rate vs free energy relation having both normal and Marcus inverted region behavior. Because the electron attachment reactions yield excited states, quantitative interpretation of the free energy dependence requires knowledge of the excited state energies. The electron enters the second lowest pi* orbital to form a pi*-pi* excited state, which quickly relaxes to the lower n-pi* excited state. The rate of attachment to this excited state is low when the free energy of reaction, Delta G degrees, is positive and increases as Delta G degrees decreases until near -0.2 eV, after which the rate decreases. While excited state energies are uncertain, reasonable estimates are obtained from absorption, excitation, and fluorescence spectra of the product radical anions measured here. The results are modeled using Marcus theory with inclusion of a high frequency molecular vibration.