Monomeric five-valence-electron bis(boryl) complexes of gallium, indium, and thallium undergo oxidative M-C bond formation with 2,3-dimethylbutadiene, in a manner consistent with both the redox properties expected for M-II species and with metal-centered radical character. The weaker nature of the M-C bond for the heavier two elements leads to the observation of reversibility in M-C bond formation (for indium) and to the isolation of products resulting from subsequent B-C reductive elimination (for both indium and thallium).