Two as-synthesized meso- and macro-porous siliceous materials (MPSMs), i.e., Al-MCM-41 and SBA-15, were mixed with tobacco to study their effect on tobacco smoke chemistry. A reference cigarette, 3R4F, and a commercial cigarette, Fortuna, containing different percentages of MPSM were smoked in a smoking machine, and the mainstream smoke was analyzed. SBA-15 showed the highest reductions of nicotine; close to 90% when it was added at 8 mass %. The superb behavior of these materials may be related to their high particulate matter filtering efficiency in combination with their catalytic activity. The selectivity of these materials with respect to nicotine was also analyzed. Al-MCM-41 presents higher selectivity for condensed compounds than for gases, whereas SBA-15 presents similar ratios for both fractions. The highest selectivity was obtained for the liquid fraction when smoking 3R4F cigarettes mixed with Al-MCM-41.