Macrocydization is a valuable tool for drug design and protein engineering. Although various methods have been developed to prepare macrocydes, a general and efficient strategy is needed. Here we report a highly efficient method using butelase 1 to macrocyclize peptides and proteins ranging in sizes from 26 to >200 residues. We achieved cyclizations that are 20,000 times faster than sortase A, the most widely used ligase for protein cyclization. The reactions completed within minutes with up to 95% yields.