To alter the versatility of interactions at its surface, TiO2 is modified with organophosphonic acids (PA). A thorough understanding of the role of all synthesis conditions is necessary to achieve controlled functionalization. This study reports on the effect of using water, toluene and their mixtures when performing the modification of TiO2 with PA. Sorption and calorimetry measurements of surface interactions with various probing species clearly indicate that, by grafting PA in water, clear differences appear in the distribution of organic groups on the surface. Also the functional group of the PA determines the impact of using water as solvent. Modification in toluene results in a higher modification degree for propylphosphonic acid (3PA), as the solvent-solute interaction may hinder the grafting with phenylphosphonic acid (PhPA) in toluene. Water is preferred as solvent for PhPA modification as stabilizing pi-OH interactions enhance surface grafting overcoming the competitive interaction of water at the surface as observed with 3PA. By using water in toluene mixtures for the functionalization of TiO2 with 3PA, the degree of functionalization is higher than when only water or toluene is used. Furthermore, adding small amounts of water leads to the formation of titanium propylphosphonates, next to surface grafting. (C) 2017 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.