For decades, discussion of asphaltene structure focused primarily on molecular weight. Now that it is widely accepted that asphaltene monomers are between similar to 250 and 1200 g/mol, disagreement has turned to asphaltene architecture. The classic island model depicts asphaltenes as single core aromatic molecules with peripheral alkyl side chains, whereas the less widely accepted archipelago model, includes multiple aromatic cores that are alkyl-bridged with multiple polar functionalities. Here, we analyze asphaltene samples by positive-ion atmospheric pressure photoionization Fourier transform ion cyclotron resonance mass spectrometry and perform infrared multiphoton dissociation to identify their aromatic core structures to shed light on the abundance of island and archipelago structural motifs. Our results indicate that island and archipelago motifs coexist in petroleum asphaltenes, and unlike readily accessible island motifs, asphaltene purification is required to detect and characterize archipelago species by mass spectrometry. Moreover, we demonstrate that mass spectrometry analysis of asphaltenic samples is biased toward the preferential ionization/detection of island structural motifs and that this bias explains the overwhelming mass spectral support of the island model. We demonstrate that the asphaltene structure is a continuum of island and archipelago motifs and hypothesize that the dominant structure (island or archipelago) depends upon the asphaltene sample.