High density polyethylene blow modling resins have been identified as a primary material for solid waste minimization and recycling. An experimental study into the effect of multiple extrusion cycles on the properties of a virgin homopolymer, virgin copolymer, natural post consumer, and mixed color post consumer blow molding resin was conducted. Rheological properties such as shear and elongational viscosity and elastic modulus were studied in the context of changes experienced during recycling. The G＇-G ＇＇ (elastic storage and loss modulus) crossover point was used to measure relative changes in the polydispersity index and molecular weight distribution (MWD). It is also shown that extrudate swell and sag change after multiple extrusion passes. Environmental stress crack resistance was also measured. A rationale for the significant decrease in the environmental stress crack resistance of the virgin copolymer resin is presented. The results are analyzed in terms of known degradation mechanisms such as chain scission and crosslinking, and their relationship to the molecular structure.