A novel method, in situ polymerization, was used for the preparation of nylon 6/silica nanocomposites, and the mechanical properties of the nanocomposites were examined. The results showed that the tensile strength, elongation at break, and impact strength of silica-modified nanocomposites exhibited a tendency of up and down with the silica content increasing, while those of silica-unmodified nanocomposites decreased gradually. It also exhibited that the mechanical properties of silica-modified nanocomposites have maximum values only when 5% silica particles were filled. Based on the relationship between impact strength of the nanocomposites and the matrix ligament thickness tau, a new criterion was proposed to explain the unique mechanical properties of nylon 6/silica nanocomposites. The nylon 6/silica nanocomposites can be toughened only when the matrix ligament thickness is less than tau(c) and greater than tau(a), where tau, is the matrix ligament thickness when silica particles begin to aggregate, and tau(c) is the critical matrix ligament thickness when silica particles begin to toughen the nylon 6 matrix. The matrix ligament thickness, tau, is not independent, which related with the volume fraction of the inorganic component because the diameter of inorganic particles remains constant during processing. According to the observation of Electron Scanning Microscope (SEM), the process of dispersion to aggregation of silica particles in the nylon 6 matrix with increasing of the silica content was observed, and this result strongly supported our proposal.