Integrated systems consisted of solar energy and air source heat pump have been a hot research topic in recent decades due to their high efficiency and low environmental pollution. Recently, much attention has been paid to the performance characteristics of these systems, however, scarce of attention has been paid to indicate which kind of integrated systems have the optimal performance under different working conditions. For the integrated system of solar heating independently, the solar collectors have high heat-collecting temperature and high heat loss to ambient, so it has advantages in high solar radiation. For the integrated system of solar energy used for the low temperature heat source of heat pumps, the solar collectors have low heat-collecting temperature and low heat loss, so it has advantages in low solar radiation. But for the condition of medium solar radiation, both the above existing two types of systems may not be the optimal ones. Therefore, in this study, a novel integrated system was put forward for this condition. The characteristics and optimal working condition range of this novel system were comparatively studied by the simulation method. By comparison with the above existing two types of systems, the results proved that for most conditions of medium solar radiation, the novel system has the optimal performance, and its COP can be about 55% higher than that of the two types of existing systems when the outdoor temperature is - 25 degrees C. An I-T diagram was proposed in this study to quantificationally divide the optimal working condition ranges of the three types of systems. This study can effectively guide the selection of optimal systems under different working conditions.