The conversion of light energy into work is essential to life on earth. Bacteriorhodopsin (bR), a light-activated proton pump in Archae, has served for many years as a model system for the study of this process in photoactive proteins. Upon absorption of a photon, its chromophore, the retinal protonated Schiff base (RPSB), isomerizes from its native all-trans form to a 13-cis form and pumps a proton out of the cell in a process that is coupled to eventual ATP synthesis. Despite numerous time-resolved spectroscopic studies over the years, the details of the photodynamics of bR on the excited state, particularly the characterization of the I fluorescent state, the time-resolved reaction mechanism, and the role of the counterion cluster of RPSB, remain uncertain. Here, we use ab initio multiple spawning (AIMS) with spin-restricted ensemble Kohn-Sham (REKS) theory to simulate the nonadiabatic dynamics of the ultrafast photoreaction in bR. The excited state dynamics can be partitioned into three distinct phases: (1) relaxation away from the Franck-Condon region dominated by changes in retinal bond length alternation, (2) dwell time on the excited state in the I fluorescent state featuring an untwisted, bond length inverted RPSB, and (3) rapid torsional evolution to the conical intersection after overcoming a small excited state barrier. We fully characterize the I fluorescent state and the excited state barrier that hinders direct evolution to the conical intersection following photoexcitation. We also find that photoisomerization is accompanied by weakening of the interaction between RPSB and its counterion cluster. However, in contradiction with a recent time-resolved X-ray experiment, hydrogen bond cleavage is not necessary to reproduce the observed photoisomerization dynamics.