Some organisms in nature that undergo anaerobic respiration utilize 1D nanoscale arrays of densely packed cytochromes containing the molecule heme. The assemblies can be mimicked with 1D nanoscale fibrils composed of peptide amphiphiles designed to coordinate heme in dense arrays. To create such materials and assemblies, it is critical to understand the assembly process and what controls the various aspects of hierarchical assembly. MD simulations suggest that shorter alkyl chains on the peptide lead to more dynamic structures than the peptides with longer chains that yield kinetically trapped states. The hydration parameters manifest themselves experimentally through the observation of a dual pH trigger, which controls the peptide assembly rate, the heme binding affinity, and heme organization kinetics. Great strides in understanding the relative complexity of the self-assembly process in relation to incorporating a functional moiety like heme opens up many possibilities in developing abiotic assemblies for bioelectronic devices and assemblies.