Nonionic surfactant interfaces are often considered to be unaffected by aqueous ions. However, ions often localize to interfaces and, as such, can interact with surfactants either via direct contact or by affecting interfacial hydrogen bond structures in water. Characterizing these effects is essential to understanding how ions affect interfacial properties at the oil-water interface in the presence of nonionic surfactants. Here, we use two-dimensional infrared (2D IR) spectroscopy in combination with atomistic molecular dynamics (MD) simulations to study the effects of high-concentration Na+ and Ca2+ ions on interfacial hydrogen bond dynamics in heterogeneous sorbitan stearate reverse micelles. Experiments show only minor changes in interfacial hydrogen bond populations when salts are added but those interfacial water network dynamics are slowed by nearly 300%. Molecular dynamics simulations show the slowdown results from an increased disorder in surfactant headgroup orientation and packing density, which stabilizes hydrogen bonding interactions between surfactants and interfacial water.