The transition between a novel oil-in-dispersion emulsion and an oil-in-water (O/W) Pickering emulsion triggered by pH was achieved using alumina nanoparticles in combination with a cationic surfactant. In acidic and neutral aqueous media, positively charged particles and the surfactant both at very low concentrations costabilize an oil-in-dispersion emulsion with the surfactant adsorbed at droplet interfaces and particles dispersed in the aqueous phase between the droplets. In alkaline media, however, particles become negatively charged and are hydro-phobized in situ by adsorption of the surfactant to become surface-active and stabilize an O/W Pickering emulsion. The transition between the two is also possible by lowering the pH. The transformation can be achieved several times in a mixture of 0.1 wt % nanoparticles and 0.01 mM surfactant. This transition is significant, since particles can be made to either adsorb at the oil-water interface, which is beneficial for applications like biphasic catalysis, or remain dispersed in the aqueous phase, which is favorable for their recovery and reuse.