화학공학소재연구정보센터
Journal of Industrial and Engineering Chemistry, Vol.104, 43-60, December, 2021
Transesterification of dimethyl carbonate with glycerol by perovskite-based mixed metal oxide nanoparticles for the atom-efficient production of glycerol carbonate
E-mail:,
The catalytic transesterification of glycerol with dimethyl carbonate (DMC) is an attractive process for the valorization of glycerol, an abundant waste product of the biodiesel industry, by its transformation in industrially attractive glycerol carbonate (GC). Interestingly, perovskites and perovskite-based mixed metal oxides (PBMMOs) were, thus far, only marginally explored for the latter reaction. In this work, a series of PBMMOs were prepared using the non-hydrolytic sol gel (NHSG) methodology as an approach to easily afford nanosized and non-aggregated ternary oxides without calcination steps. The prepared materials were characterized via TEM and SEM microscopies, XRD analysis, XPS, BET surface area and TPD measurements showing that the as-synthesized PBMMOs displayed higher surface areas and larger number of crucial strong basic sites than their analogues produced by calcination at 1000 °C. The catalytic activity of as-synthesized or calcined PBMMOs followed a clear linear trend as a function of the materials basicity with the most basic PBMMOs (SrTiO3-200, YNbO4-200 and BaCeO3-200) performing as the most active catalysts. Selected materials on the basis of catalytic performance and low metal toxicity (SrTiO3- 200, YNbO4-200) were subsequently applied to improve the atom economy of the transesterification reaction using low (1:2 or 1:1.5) DMC/glycerol ratios and even equimolar amounts of reagents. Under optimized conditions, the use of SrTiO3-200 as the catalyst allowed the quantitative and selective conversion of glycerol to GC by using 1:2 DMC/glycerol ratio and could be efficiently recycled maintaining at least 95% GC yield at the fifth catalytic run. Albeit slightly less active than SrTiO3-200, YNbO4-200 performed well when working with equimolar DMC/glycerol ratio allowing glycerol conversion and GC yield over 80%.
  1. Schaffner B, Schaffner F, Verevkin SP, Borner A, Chem. Rev., 110(8), 4554 (2010)
  2. Lawrenson SB, Arav R, North M, Green Chem., 19, 1685 (2017)
  3. Rasool MA, Pescarmona PP, Vankelecom IFJ, ACS Sustainable Chem. Eng., 7, 13774 (2019)
  4. Kamphuis AJ, Picchioni F, Pescarmona PP, Green Chem., 21, 406 (2019)
  5. Yadav N, Seidi F, Crespy D, D’Elia V, ChemSusChem, 12, 724 (2019)
  6. Grignard B, Gennen S, Jerome C, Kleij AW, Detrembleur C, Chem. Soc. Rev., 48, 4466 (2019)
  7. Guo W, Gomez JE, Cristofol A, Xie J, Kleij AW, Angew. Chem.-Int. Edit., 57, 13735 (2018)
  8. Guo WS, Kuniyil R, Gomez JE, Maseras F, Kleij AW, J. Am. Chem. Soc., 140(11), 3981 (2018)
  9. Sonnati MO, Amigoni S, Taffin de Givenchy EP, Darmanin T, Choulet O, Guittard F, Green Chem., 15, 283 (2013)
  10. Quienne B, Kasmi N, Dieden R, Caillol S, Habibi Y, Biomacromolecules, 21(5), 1943 (2020)
  11. Yadav N, Seidi F, Del Gobbo S, D’Elia V, Crespy D, Polym. Chem., 10, 3571 (2019)
  12. Szori M, Giri BR, Wang Z, Dawood AE, Viskolcz B, Farooq A, Sustainable Energy Fuels, 2, 2171 (2018)
  13. Rasool MA, Vankelecom IFJ, Green Chem., 21, 1054 (2019)
  14. Magliozzi F, Chollet G, Grau E, Cramail H, ACS Sustainable Chem. Eng., 7, 17282 (2019)
  15. Tabanelli T, Giliberti C, Mazzoni R, Cucciniello R, Cavani F, Green Chem., 21, 329 (2019)
  16. Aomchad V, Cristofol A, Della Monica F, Limburg B, D’Elia V, Kleij AW, Green Chem., 23, 1077 (2021)
  17. Dabral S, Schaub T, Adv. Synth. Catal., 361, 223 (2019)
  18. Artz J, Muller TE, Thenert K, Kleinekorte J, Meys R, Sternberg A, Bardow A, Leitner W, Chem. Rev., 118, 434 (2017)
  19. Tappe NA, Reich RM, D’Elia V, Kuhn FE, Dalton Trans., 47, 13281 (2018)
  20. Song QW, Zhou ZH, He LN, Green Chem., 19, 3707 (2017)
  21. North M, Pasquale R, Young C, Green Chem., 12, 1514 (2010)
  22. Martin C, Fiorani G, Kleij AW, ACS Catal., 5, 1353 (2015)
  23. Buttner H, Longwitz L, Steinbauer J, Wulf C, Werner T, Top. Curr. Chem., 375, 2017
  24. Shaikh RR, Pornpraprom S, D’ Elia V, ACS Catal., 8, 419 (2018)
  25. Cokoja M, Wilhelm ME, Anthofer MH, Herrmann WA, Kuhn FE, ChemSusChem, 8, 2436 (2015)
  26. Li X, Liu X, Liu J, Ren L, Hu X, Wu Y, Zhang F, Zhang Z, Appl. Catal. B: Environ., 283, 119629 (2020)
  27. Zanda N, Sobolewska A, Alza E, Kleij AW, Pericas MA, ACS Sustainable Chem. Eng., 9, 4391 (2021)
  28. Maeda C, Shimonishi J, Miyazaki R, Hasegawa JY, Ema T, Chem. Eur. J., 22, 6556 (2016)
  29. Whiteoak CJ, Nova A, Maseras F, Kleij AW, ChemSusChem, 5, 2032 (2012)
  30. Steinbauer J, Spannenberg A, Werner T, Green Chem., 19, 3769 (2017)
  31. Yingcharoen P, Kongtes C, Arayachukiat S, Suvarnapunya K, Vummaleti SVC, Wannakao S, Cavallo L, Poater A, D’ Elia V, Adv. Synth. Catal., 361, 366 (2019)
  32. Barthel A, Saih Y, Gimenez M, Pelletier JDA, Kuhn FE, D’Elia V, Basset JM, Green Chem., 18, 3116 (2016)
  33. Sodpiban O, Phungpanya C, Del Gobbo S, Arayachukiat S, Piromchart T, D’Elia V, Chem. Eng. J., 422, 129930 (2021)
  34. von der Assen N, Bardow A, Green Chem., 16, 3272 (2014)
  35. Honda M, Tamura M, Nakao K, Suzuki K, Nakagawa Y, Tomishige K, ACS Catal., 4, 1893 (2014)
  36. Guidi S, Calmanti R, Noe M, Perosa A, Selva M, ACS Sustainable Chem. Eng., 4, 6144 (2016)
  37. Tan HW, Abdul Aziz AR, Aroua MK, Renew. Sust. Energ. Rev., 27, 118 (2013)
  38. Liu JX, Li YM, Zhang J, He DH, Appl. Catal. A: Gen., 513, 9 (2016)
  39. Liu JX, Li YJ, Liu HM, He DH, Appl. Catal. B: Environ., 244, 836 (2019)
  40. Li Y, Liu H, Ma L, Liu J, He D, Catal. Sci. Technol., 11, 1007 (2021)
  41. Ozorio LP, Mota CJA, ChemphysChem, 18, 3260 (2017)
  42. Zhang Q, Yuan HY, Lin XT, Fukaya N, Fujitani T, Sato K, Choi JC, Green Chem., 22, 4231 (2020)
  43. Hu C, Chang CW, Yoshida M, Wang KH, J. Mater. Chem. A, 9, 7048 (2021)
  44. Ochoa-Gomez JR, Gomez-Jimenez-Aberasturi O, Ramirez-Lopez C, Belsue M, Org. Process Res. Dev., 16, 389 (2012)
  45. Costanzo P, Calandruccio C, Di Gioia ML, Nardi M, Oliverio M, Procopio A, J. Clean Prod., 202, 504 (2018)
  46. Wang DF, Zhang XL, Cong XS, Liu SF, Zhou DG, Appl. Catal. A: Gen., 555, 36 (2018)
  47. Gerardy R, Estager J, Luis P, Debecker DP, Monbaliu JCM, Catal. Sci. Technol., 9, 6841 (2019)
  48. Manjunathan P, Ravishankar R, Shanbhag GV, ChemCatChem, 8, 631 (2016)
  49. Huy NP, Shin EW, J. Catal., 373, 147 (2019)
  50. Fiorani G, Perosa A, Selva M, Green Chem., 20, 288 (2018)
  51. Teng WK, Ngoh GC, Yusoff R, Aroua MK, Energy Conv. Manag., 88, 484 (2014)
  52. Ji Y, Catalysts, 9, 581 (2019)
  53. Sahani S, Upadhyay SN, Sharma YC, Ind. Eng. Chem. Res., 60, 67 (2020)
  54. Nogueira DO, de Souza SP, Leao RAC, Miranda LSM, de Souza ROMA, RSC Adv., 5, 20945 (2015)
  55. Munshi MK, Gade SM, Rane VH, Kelkar AA, RSC Adv., 4, 32127 (2014)
  56. Hervert B, McCarthy PD, Palencia H, Tetrahedron Lett., 55, 133 (2014)
  57. Munshi MK, Gade SM, Mane MV, Mishra D, Pal S, Vanka K, Rane VH, Kelkar AA, J. Mol. Catal. A-Chem., 391, 144 (2014)
  58. Ochoa-Gomez JR, Gomez-Jimenez-Aberasturi O, Ramirez-Lopez C, Maestro-Madurga B, Green Chem., 14, 3368 (2012)
  59. Wang H, Lu B, Wang XG, Zhang JW, Cai QH, Fuel Process. Technol., 90(10), 1198 (2009)
  60. Van Mileghem S, De Borggraeve WM, Baxendale IR, Chem. Eng. Technol., 41(10), 2014 (2018)
  61. Simanjuntak FSH, Choi JS, Lee G, Lee HJ, Lee SD, Cheong M, Kim HS, Lee H, Appl. Catal. B: Environ., 165, 642 (2015)
  62. Shikhaliyev K, Hameed BH, Okoye PU, J. Environ. Chem. Eng., 9, 104768 (2021)
  63. Shikhaliyev K, Okoye PU, Hameed BH, Energy Conv. Manag., 165, 794 (2018)
  64. Lee HJL, Deuk S, Moon DJ, Park JH, Simanjuntak FSH, KR2011116600 (2011).
  65. Ochoa-Gomez JR, Gomez-Jimenez-Aberasturi O, Maestro-Madurga B, Pesquera-Rodriguez A, Ramirez-Lopez C, Lorenzo-Ibarreta L, Torrecilla-Soria J, Villaran-Velasco MC, Appl. Catal. A: Gen., 366(2), 315 (2009)
  66. Simanjuntak FSH, Lim SR, Ahn BS, Kim HS, Lee H, Appl. Catal. A: Gen., 484, 33 (2014)
  67. Simanjuntak FSH, Kim TK, Lee SD, Ahn BS, Kim HS, Lee H, Appl. Catal. A: Gen., 401(1-2), 220 (2011)
  68. Li J, Wang T, React. Kinet. Mech. Catal., 102, 113 (2010)
  69. Teng WK, Yusoff R, Aroua MK, Nogh GC, Sustainable Energy Fuels, 5, 274 (2021)
  70. Li YJ, Liu JX, He DH, Appl. Catal. A: Gen., 564, 234 (2018)
  71. Song XH, Wu YF, Cai FF, Pan DH, Xiao GM, Appl. Catal. A: Gen., 532, 77 (2017)
  72. Pradhan G, Sharma YC, Fuel, 284, 118966 (2021)
  73. Arora S, Gosu V, Kumar UKA, Subbaramaiah V, J. Clean Prod., 295 (2021)
  74. Malyaadri M, Jagadeeswaraiah K, Prasad PSS, Lingaiah N, Appl. Catal. A: Gen., 401(1-2), 153 (2011)
  75. Parameswaram G, Srinivas M, Babu BH, Prasad PSS, Lingaiah N, Catal. Sci. Technol., 3, 3242 (2013)
  76. Zhang X, Wei S, Zhao X, Chen Z, Wu H, Rong P, Sun Y, Li Y, Yu H, Wang D, Appl. Catal. A: Gen., 590, 117313 (2020)
  77. Kumar P, With P, Srivastava VC, Glaser R, Mishra IM, Ind. Eng. Chem. Res., 54(50), 12543 (2015)
  78. Takagaki A, Iwatani K, Nishimura S, Ebitani K, Green Chem., 12, 578 (2010)
  79. Alvarez MG, Frey AM, Bitter JH, Segarra AM, de Jong KP, Medina F, Appl. Catal. B: Environ., 134-135, 231 (2013)
  80. Alvarez MG, Pliskova M, Segarra AM, Medina F, Figueras F, Appl. Catal. B: Environ., 113-114, 212 (2012)
  81. Sun YL, Gao X, Yang N, Tantai XW, Xiao XM, Jiang B, Zhang LH, Ind. Eng. Chem. Res., 58(19), 7937 (2019)
  82. Granados-Reyes J, Salagre P, Cesteros Y, Appl. Catal. A: Gen., 536, 9 (2017)
  83. Ramesh S, Debecker DP, Catal. Commun., 97, 102 (2017)
  84. Ramesh S, Devred F, van den Biggelaar L, Debecker DP, ChemCatChem, 10, 1398 (2018)
  85. Okoye PU, Abdullah AZ, Hameed BH, Energy Conv. Manag., 133, 477 (2017)
  86. Phadtare D, Kondawar S, Athawale A, Rode C, Mol. Catal., 475, 110496 (2019)
  87. Okoye PU, Abdullah AZ, Hameed BH, J. Taiwan Inst. Chem. Eng, 68, 51 (2016)
  88. 12 Principle of Green Chemistry, American Chemical Society.
  89. Algoufi YT, Akpan UG, Kabir G, Asif M, Hameed BH, Energy Conv. Manag., 138, 183 (2017)
  90. Bai RX, Wang Y, Wang S, Mei FM, Li T, Li GX, Fuel Process. Technol., 106, 209 (2013)
  91. Li JB, Wang T, Chem. Eng. Process., 49(5), 530 (2010)
  92. Grabowska E, Appl. Catal. B: Environ., 186, 97 (2016)
  93. Fulle K, McMillen CD, Sanjeewa LD, Kolis JW, Cryst. Growth Des., 16, 4910 (2016)
  94. Hwang J, Rao RR, Giordano L, Katayama Y, Yu Y, Shao-Horn Y, Science, 358(6364), 751 (2017)
  95. Zhu J, Li H, Zhong L, Xiao P, Xu X, Yang X, Zhao Z, Li J, ACS Catal., 4, 2917 (2014)
  96. Yadav GD, Chandan PA, Catal. Today, 237, 47 (2014)
  97. Kaur A, Ali A, Ind. Eng. Chem. Res., 59(7), 2667 (2020)
  98. Polo-Garzon F, Wu Z, J. Mater. Chem. A, 6, 2877 (2018)
  99. Shamsi J, Urban AS, Imran M, De Trizio L, Manna L, Chem. Rev., 119(5), 3296 (2019)
  100. Kulkarni SA, Mhaisalkar SG, Mathews N, Boix PP, Small Methods, 3, 1 (2019)
  101. Kondawar SE, Patil CR, Rode CV, ACS Sustainable Chem. Eng., 5, 1763 (2016)
  102. Ngida REA, Zawrah NF, Khattab RM, Heikal E, Ceram. Int., 45, 4894 (2019)
  103. Feldhoff A, Arnold M, Martynczuk J, Gesing TM, Wang H, Solid State Sci., 10, 689 (2008)
  104. Zhang JY, Weng XL, Wu ZB, Liu Y, Wang HQ, Appl. Catal. B: Environ., 126, 231 (2012)
  105. Lan C, Zhou Z, Wei R, Ho JC, Mater. Today Energy, 11, 61 (2019)
  106. Walton RI, Chem. Eur. J., 26, 9041 (2020)
  107. Lee DW, Won JH, Shim KB, Mater. Lett., 57, 3346 (2003)
  108. Rida K, Pena MA, Sastre E, Martinez-Arias A, J. Rare Earths, 30, 210 (2012)
  109. Mi L, Zhang Q, Wang H, Wu Z, Guo Y, Li Y, Xiong X, Liu K, Fu W, Ma Y, Wang B, Qi X, Ceram. Int., 46, 10619 (2020)
  110. Sharma N, Gaur A, Kr Gaur U, Ceram. Int., 40, 16441 (2014)
  111. Niederberger M, Pinna N, Polleux J, Antonietti M, Angew. Chem.-Int. Edit., 43, 2270 (2004)
  112. Deshmukh R, Niederberger M, Non hydrolytic Sol-Gel Methods, In The Sol-Gel Handbook Wiley-VCH, Weinheim (Germany), Ch. 2, pp. 29, 2015.
  113. Liu LC, Corma A, Chem. Rev., 118(10), 4981 (2018)
  114. Samantaray MK, D’Elia V, Pump E, Falivene L, Harb M, Chikh SO, Cavallo L, Basset JM, Chem. Rev., 120, 734 (2019)
  115. Rondelli M, Zwaschka G, Krause M, Rotzer MD, Hedhili MN, Hogerl MP, D’Elia V, Schweinberger FF, Basset JM, Heiz U, ACS Catal., 7, 4152 (2017)
  116. Niederberger M, Garnweitner G, Pinna N, Antonietti M, J. Am. Chem. Soc., 126(29), 9120 (2004)
  117. Zhang L, Garnweitner G, Djerdj I, Antonietti M, Niederberger M, Chem. Asian J., 3, 746 (2008)
  118. Shabanikia A, Javanbakht M, Amoli HS, Hooshyari K, Enhessari M, Electrochim. Acta, 154, 370 (2015)
  119. Duong HP, Mashiyama T, Kobayashi M, Iwase A, Kudo A, Asakura Y, Yin S, Kakihana M, Kato H, Appl. Catal. B: Environ., 252, 222 (2019)
  120. Lin Q, Zhu Y, Hu Z, Yin Y, Lin HJ, Chen CT, Zhang X, Shao Z, Wang H, J. Mater. Chem. A, 8, 6480 (2020)
  121. Kucharczyk B, Okal J, Tylus W, Winiarski J, Szczygieł B, Ceram. Int., 45, 2779 (2019)
  122. Kannan R, Singh K, Gill S, Furstenhaupt T, Thangadurai V, Sci. Rep., 3, 2138 (2013)
  123. Selvaraj M, Venkatachalapathy V, Mayandi J, Karazhanov S, Pearce JM, AIP Adv., 5, 117119 (2015)
  124. Zhou H, Mao Y, Wong SS, J. Mater. Chem., 17, 1707 (2007)
  125. Azough F, Gholinia A, Alvarez-Ruiz DT, Duran E, Kepaptsoglou DM, Eggeman AS, Ramasse QM, Freer R, ACS Appl. Mater. Interfaces, 11, 32833 (2019)
  126. Yang P, Quan Z, Li C, Yang J, Wang H, Liu X, Liu J, J. Solid State Chem., 181, 1943 (2008)
  127. Sundaresan P, Karthik R, Chen SM, Kumar JV, Muthuraj V, Nagarajan ER, Ultrason. Sonochem., 53, 44 (2019)
  128. Gupta SK, Sahu M, Krishnan K, Saxena MK, Natarajan V, Godbole SV, J. Mater. Chem. C, 1, 7054 (2013)
  129. Rocha LA, Schiavon MA, Nascimento CS, Guimaraes L, et al., J. Alloy. Compd., 608, 73 (2014)
  130. Hirano M, Dozono H, J. Am. Ceram. Soc., 96(11), 3389 (2013)
  131. Kim M, Ronchetti S, Onida B, Ichikuni N, Fukuoka A, Kato H, Nakajima K, ChemCatChem, 12, 350 (2019)
  132. Santara B, Giri PK, Imakita K, Fujii M, J. Phys. D-Appl. Phys., 47, 215302 (2014)
  133. Miodynska M, Bajorowicz B, Mazierski P, Lisowski W, Klimczuk T, Winiarski MJ, Zaleska-Medynska Z, Nadolna J, Solid State Sci., 74, 13 (2017)
  134. Karslıoglu O, Trotochaud L, Zegkinoglou I, Bluhm H, J. Electron. Spectrosc. Relat. Phenomena, 225, 55 (2018).
  135. Talik E, Lipinska L, Skrzypek D, Skuta A, Zajdel P, Guzik A, Duda H, Mater. Res. Bull., 47(11), 3107 (2012)
  136. Dupin JC, Gonbeau D, Vinatier P, Levasseur A, Phys. Chem. Chem. Phys., 2, 1319 (2000)
  137. McCafferty E, Wightman JP, Surf. Interface Anal., 26, 549 (1998)
  138. Zhou X, Liu N, Yokosawa T, Osvet A, Miehlich ME, Meyer K, Spiecker E, Schmuki P, ACS Appl. Mater. Interfaces, 10, 29532 (2018)
  139. Panigrahy B, Aslam M, Misra DS, Ghosh M, Bahadur D, Adv. Funct. Mater., 20(7), 1161 (2010)
  140. Maity N, Barman S, Minenkov Y, Ould-Chikh S, Abou-Hamad E, Ma T, Qureshi ZS, Cavallo L, D’Elia V, Gates BC, Basset JM, ACS Catal., 8, 2715 (2018)
  141. Neißer-Deiters A, Scherb S, Beuntner N, Thienel KC, Appl. Clay Sci., 179, 105168 (2019)
  142. Yu J, Ran R, Zhong Y, Zhou W, Ni M, Shao Z, Energy Environ. Mater., 3, 121 (2020)
  143. Khayoon MS, Hameed BH, Appl. Catal. A: Gen., 466, 272 (2013)
  144. Song X, Pan D, Wu Y, Cheng P, Wei R, Gao L, Zhang J, Xiao G, J. Alloy. Compd., 750, 828 (2018)
  145. Xiang M, Wu D, RSC Adv., 8, 33473 (2018)
  146. Khanday WA, Okoye PU, Hameed BH, Energy Conv. Manag., 151, 472 (2017)
  147. Di Serio M, Ledda M, Cozzolino M, Minutillo G, Tesser R, Santacesaria E, Ind. Eng. Chem. Res., 45(9), 3009 (2006)
  148. Zhang Z, Wang Y, Wang M, Lu J, Zhang C, Li L, Jiang J, Wang F, Catal. Sci. Technol., 6, 1693 (2016)
  149. Liu MH, Wu XD, Liu S, Gao YX, Chen Z, Ma Y, Ran R, Weng D, Appl. Catal. B: Environ., 219, 231 (2017)
  150. Wu H, Pantaleo G, Di Carlo G, Guo S, Marci G, Concepcion P, Venezia AM, Liotta LF, Catal. Sci. Technol., 5, 1888 (2015)
  151. de Rivas B, Lopez-Fonseca R, Jimenez-Gonzalez C, Gutierrez-Ortiz JI, J. Catal., 281(1), 88 (2011)
  152. Bai L, Polo-Garzon F, Bao Z, Luo S, Moskowitz BM, Tian H, Wu Z, ChemCatChem, 11, 2107 (2019)
  153. Bhoelan BS, Stevering CH, van der Boog ATJ, van der Heyden MAG, Clin. Toxicol., 52, 584 (2014)
  154. Burger A, Lichtscheidl I, Sci. Total Environ., 653, 1458 (2019)
  155. Simanjuntak FSH, Widyaya VT, Kim CS, Ahn BS, Kim YJ, Lee H, Chem. Eng. Sci., 94, 265 (2013)
  156. Parameswaram G, Rao PSN, Srivani A, Rao GN, Lingaiah N, Mol. Catal., 451, 135 (2018)
  157. Okoye PU, Wang S, Xu LL, Li SX, Wang JY, Zhang LN, Energy Conv. Manag., 179, 192 (2019)
  158. Liu P, Derchi M, Hensen EJM, Appl. Catal. A: Gen., 467, 124 (2013)
  159. Das B, Mohanty K, J. Environ. Chem. Eng., 7, 102888 (2019)
  160. Das B, Mohanty K, Ind. Eng. Chem. Res., 58(35), 15803 (2019)
  161. Marquez C, Rivera-Torrente M, Paalanen PP, Weckhuysen BM, Cirujano FG, De Vos D, De Baerdemaeker T, J. Catal., 354, 92 (2017)
  162. Barman S, Maity N, Bhatte K, et al., ACS Catal, 6, 5908 (2016)
  163. Jiang K, Luo M, Peng M, Yu Y, Lu YR, Chan TS, Liu P, de Groot FMF, Tan Y, Nat. Commun., 11, 2701 (2020)
  164. Fako E, Łodziana Z, Lopez N, Catal. Sci. Technol., 7, 4285 (2017)
  165. Wang S, Xu LL, Okoye PU, Li SX, Tian CC, Energy Conv. Manag., 164, 543 (2018)
  166. Afzal S, Quan X, Zhang JL, Appl. Catal. B: Environ., 206, 692 (2017)