The hydrogen-donor solvent (H-donor) used in direct coal liquefaction (DCL) plays a critical role in both the oil yield and distribution of the products. However, the mechanism of the reaction between H-donor and coal in the DCL is unclear. In this study, the reaction of H-donor and coal in the DCL was investigated using the model compounds tetralin (H-donor) and diphenylmethane (DPM, coal). Density functional theory calculations were employed to examine both pyrolytic radical and solvent-mediated hydrogenolysis mechanisms. Based on the computed results, a modified solvent-mediated hydrogenolysis mechanism was proposed, namely the synergistic double-hydrogen-transfer mechanism, in which the beta- and alpha-hydrogen atoms simultaneously transfer from tetralin to the ipso- and meta-carbon atoms of DPM. The calculated energy barriers of hydrogen transfer were lower than most of the bond dissociation enthalpies for coal. The energy barriers range of the synergistic doublehydrogen-transfer reaction did not correlate with the dissociation enthalpies of Caryl- Calkyl bond, although they were consistent with the order of the hydrogen-donating abilities of different solvents. This study may provide a theoretical guidance to improve the efficiency of H-donor in the DCL.