Group 4 phosphides, which are typically prepared at high temperatures (>800 degrees C) over several days, are synthesized in self-propagating metathesis (exchange) reactions in seconds. These reactions produce cubic forms of zirconium phosphide (ZrP) and hafnium phosphide (HfP) which are normally made at temperatures greater than 1425 degrees C and 1600 degrees C, respectively. To test whether the high temperatures reached in the metathesis reactions are responsible for the formation of the cubic phases, inert salts are added to lower the maximum reaction temperatures. The lower temperature reactions still result in cubic phosphides, although smaller crystallites form. Further experiments with phosphorus addition indicate that the phosphorus content is not responsible for cubic phase formation. Templating is ruled out using lattice mismatched KCl and hexagonal ZnS as additives. Therefore, the direct synthesis of the high-temperature cubic phase in metathesis reactions appears to be caused by nucleation of the metastable cubic form that is then trapped by rapid cooling. Heating the cubic phase of either ZrP or HfP to 1000 degrees C for 18 h, or carrying out metathesis reactions in sealed ampules at 1000 degrees C, results only in the hexagonal phase.