We have studied the refractive index of a thin aqueous film between microscopic hydrophobic surfaces using evanescent wave atomic force microscopy (EW-AFM). An evanescent wave, generated at a solid-liquid interface, is scattered by AFM tips or glass particles attached to AFM cantilevers. The scattering of this wave is used to determine the refractive index as a function of separation between these surfaces. Measurements were performed on surfaces that were rendered hydrophobic with octadecyltrichlorosilane, which produces solid-water contact angles in excess of 90 degrees. For AFM tips, the average refractive index in the thin film was always equal to that of water when the film was thicker than similar to 100 nm. At smaller separations, the refractive index was always greater than or equal to that of water. This is inconsistent with the formation of air or vapor films and consistent with a small amount of organic material between the surfaces. For colloidal spheres (R similar to 10 mu m), we were not able to detect changes in the refractive index of the thin film between the sphere and plate.