Carbonate and chloride ions mediate an ordered stacking of metal hydroxide slabs to yield ordered layered double hydroxides (LDHs) of Zn with Al, by virtue of their ability to occupy crystallographically well-defined interlayer sites. Other anions such as ClO4- (T-d), BrO3-(C-3v), and NO3- (coordination symmetry C-2v) whose symmetry does not match the symmetry of the interlayer sites (D-3h or Oh) introduce a significant number of stacking faults, leading to turbostratic disorder. SO42- ions (coordination symmetry C-3v) alter the long-range stacking of the metal hydroxide slabs to nucleate a different polytype. The degree of disorder is also affected by the method of synthesis. Anion-exchange reactions yield a solid with a greater degree of order if the incoming ion is a CO32- or Cl-. Incoming NO3- ions yield an interstratified phase, whereas incoming SO42- ions generate turbostratic disorder. Conservation or its converse, elimination, of stacking disorders during anion exchange is the net result of several competing factors such as (i) the orientation of the hydroxyl groups in the interlayer region, (ii) the symmetry of the interlayer sites, (iii) the symmetry of the incoming ion, and (iv) the configuration of the anion. These short-range interactions ultimately affect the long- range stacking order or "crystallinity" of the LDH.