UDP-galactopyranose mutase (UGM) is the key enzyme involved in the biosynthesis of Galf. UDP-Galp and UDP-Galf are two natural substrates of UGM. A protocol that combines the use of STD-NMR spectroscopy, molecular modeling, and CORCEMA-ST calculations was applied to the investigation of the binding of UDP-Galf and its C3-fluorinated analogue to UGM from Klebsiella pneumoniae. UDP-Galf and UDP-[3-F]Galf were bound to UGM in a manner similar to that of UDP-Galp. The interconversions of UDP-Galf and UDP-[3-F]Galf to their galactopyranose counterparts were catalyzed by the reduced (active) UGM with different catalytic efficiencies, as observed by NMR spectroscopy. The binding affinities of UDP-Galf and UDP-[3-F]Galf were also compared with those of UDP-Galp and UDP by competition STD-NMR experiments. When UGM was in the oxidized (inactive) state, the binding affinities of UDP-Galf, UDP-Galp, and UDP-[3-F]Galf were of similar magnitudes and were lower than that of UDP. However, when UGM was in the reduced state, UDP-Galp had higher binding affinity compared with UDP. Molecular dynamics (MD) simulations indicated that the "open" mobile loop in UGM "closes" upon binding of the substrates. Combined MD simulations and STD-NMR experiments were used to create models of UGM with UDP-Galf and UDP-[3-F]Galf as bound ligands. Calculated values of saturation-transfer effects with CORCEMA-ST (complete relaxation and conformational exchange matrix analysis of saturation transfer) were compared to the experimental STD effects and permitted differentiation between two main conformational families of the bound ligands. Taken together, these results are used to rationalize the different rates of catalytic turnover of UDP-Galf and UDP-[3-F]Galf and shed light on the mechanism of action of UGM.