The study of polymer behavior over time represents the crucial stage in the setup of innovative methodologies for paper restoration. In this research, a series of laboratory simulations by accelerated aging and characterization tests by chemical and physical measurements were carried out on paper samples consolidated both by grafting polymerization with acrylic copolymers and by coating with waterborne polyurethanes with the aim of determining their harmlessness and long-term effectiveness. In this way, our purpose was not only to verify possible risks for the paper materials but also to determine the advantages and potentialities of new restoration methods through an appropriate and essential working plan of investigations. From our evaluation, both the selected consolidation methods appeared unsuitable to be used in paper restoration because of the damage that they could cause on the paper materials because of their limited durability over time. (C) 2009 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. J Appl Polym Sci 112: 3529-3536, 2009