For a range of protein substrates, N-terminal transamination offers a convenient way to install a reactive ketone or aldehyde functional group at a single location. We report herein the effects of the identity of N-terminal residues on the product distribution generated upon reaction with pyridoxal 5'-phosphate (PLP). This study was accomplished through the combination of solid-phase peptide synthesis with detailed liquid chromatography-mass spectrometry analysis. Many N-terminal amino acids provided high yields of the desired transaminated products, but some residues (His, Trp, Lys, and Pro) generated adducts with PLP itself. N-terminal Cys and Ser residues were observed to undergo beta-elimination in addition to transamination, and the transamination product of N-terminal Gln was resistant to subsequent oxime formation attempts. The information generated through the screening of peptide substrates was successfully applied to a protein target, changing an initially unreactive terminus into one that could be modified in high (70%) yield. Thus, these studies have increased our predictive power for the reaction, both in terms of improving conversion and suppressing reaction byproducts. An initial set of guidelines that may be used to increase the applicability of this reaction to specific proteins of interest is provided.