We describe the assembly of two-component, hydrogel microparticle (microgel) monolayer films onto solid substrates via passive Coulombic adsorption from solution. By using two different microgel types with nearly identical sizes but different degrees of softness, the influence of particle deformation on film composition was determined. Determination of the microgel properties using a variety of light scattering techniques allowed for predictions of the film composition as a function of solution composition using a random sequential adsorption (RSA) model. The films were then studied via atomic force microscopy (AFM), and surface coverage and population statistics were determined from the images and compared to the model predictions. Deviations from the predicted particle adsorption behavior can be directly traced to differences in particle softness, deformation, and particle footprint following adsorption, which biases the particle coverage to the more rigid (smaller footprint) particles. Furthermore, by using a mixture of degradable and nondegradable core/shell particles, the identity of the particles can be unambiguously determined by measuring AFM height changes following erosion of the core from the microgels. These results show that, regardless of the solution diffusion properties of soft particles, their competition for surface adsorption from a binary mixture is largely dictated by their interactions with the surface and their deformation at the surface.