Methanol electrooxidation on smooth Pt and PtRu bulk alloys and carbon-supported Pt and PtRu nanoparticle catalysts has been studied using cyclic voltammetry and potential step chronoamperometry combined with differential electrochemical mass spectrometry (DEMS). The current efficiencies for generated CO2 and methyl formate were calculated from Faradaic current (coulometric charge) and mass spectrometric currents (charges) at m/z = 44 and m/z = 60. The effects of Ru content in PtRu catalysts, catalyst loading/roughness, and the concentration of sulfuric acid as supporting electrolyte on the reaction kinetics and product distribution during methanol electrooxidation have been investigated. The results indicate that Pt-rich PtRu alloys and carbon-supported PtRu catalysts with ca. 20 atom % Ru content exhibit the highest catalytic activity for methanol electrooxidation, that is, the highest Faradaic current and the highest current efficiency for CO2 generation at low applied potentials. As the catalyst loading/roughness increases, the current efficiency for CO2 formation increases due to the further oxidation of soluble intermediates (formaldehyde and formic acid). At high concentrations of sulfuric acid, the electrooxidation of methanol was suppressed; both the oxidative current and the current efficiency of CO2 decreased, likely due to sulfate/bisulfate adsorption.