The delineation Ben Nevis L-55 well, located in the Hebron-Ben Nevis field, offshore Newfoundland, targeted the Cretaceous Ben Nevis Formation in the petroleum-rich Jeanne d'Arc Basin. This case study focuses on the bioturbated net-pay horizons and assesses the importance of animal-sediment interactions in controlling the porosity and permeability of sandstone reservoir intervals. Our data reveal that bioturbation can either reduce permeability and porosity by as much as approximately 33% or enhance it by up to 600%, dependent on burrow type and behavior of the trace-making organism. The net-pay interval in the cored interval of Ben Nevis L-55 is characterized by Ophiomorpha-dominated ichnofabrics. The action of bioturbators can be classified in terms of sediment mixing, sediment cleaning, sediment packing, and pipe-work-building strategies. Bioturbation has the potential to (1) increase isotropy or uniformity of grain size by destroying sedimentary laminae through burrow homogenization, or (2) decrease isotropy by selectively sorting grains into burrow lining and fill by grain size, and through creation of open-burrow systems filled with later sediments of differing character to the host sediment. The petrophysical characteristics of the reservoir facies are highly dependent on trace fossil morphology, presence or absence of burrow linings, nature of burrow fills, burrow size, and bioturbation intensity. Mudstone-rich facies and ichno-fabrics containing mudstone-filled and/or lined burrows (e.g., Ophiomorpha and clusters of Chondrites) have the net effect of permeability reduction. In contrast, permeability enhancement is documented from muddy sandstone facies with clean sand-filled burrows (e.g., Thalassinoides) and clean sandstones with burrow-mottled or diffuse to massive textures.