Carbon monoxide is a key intermediate in the electrochemical reduction of carbon dioxide to methane and ethylene on copper electrodes. We investigated the electrochemical reduction of CO on two single-crystal copper electrodes and observed two different reaction mechanisms for ethylene formation: one pathway has a common intermediate with the formation of methane and takes place preferentially at (111) facets or steps, and the other pathway involves selective reduction of CO to ethylene at relatively low overpotentials at (100) facets. The (100) facets seem to be the dominant crystal facets in polycrystalline copper, opening up new routes to affordable (photo)electrochemical production of hydrocarbons from CO2.